To call the movie "Up in the
Air" directed by Jason Reitman, produced and released in 2009, and the
book “Up in the Air" by Walter Kirn, published in 2001,
the same would be like comparing different languages. First and foremost, the
book and movie are speaking to two different audiences. Both mediums offer the
same "general background" as far as plot is concerned, however there
are major differences in the delivery systems of the plot. The book paints Ryan
as a self satisfied almost narcissist who flies around the country firing
people for larger corporations. The movie, in which he has the same job, paints
him as a hopeless romantic living in Airworld, a self-made utopia in which Ryan
lives. There are many more differences between the movie and the book, which
leads one to believe that the differences between the movie and book are so substantial
due to the major differences in the times in America. One being created in a
pre-Iraq war and one created post Iraqi war. These major differences between
the two mediums are essential to the delivery of the message the story
contains.
First and foremost, the largest
advantage that the country has brought through is technology. The upraise of
technology in the United States has been vast. During The first 20 minutes of the movie, they
bring in a specialist attempting to minimize the expenditures of Ryan’s
company. To do this, she proposes firing individuals through video chat. Yes,
this service was available in 2001 when Kirn wrote the book, however at that
time, this service wasn’t available as a reasonable alternative to face to face
confrontation. With today’s mass technological advantages, many companies are
turning to this method to perform many everyday tasks. In the book, Ryan speaks
of using a HandStar, antiquated by
todays terms, however top of the technological chain during the time. In the
movie, Ryan simply uses his computer or his phone. In the movie, Alex, Ryan’s
steady fling, mentions “googleing” Ryan And states that “that’s the thing that
modern day girls do when they have a crush.” In the book, there is no mention
of Google being a means of researching an individual.
Next among the major differences
are the economical hardships in which this country finds itself today. In mid
2001, the American businessman jetted from one side of the country to the other
without thinking twice. By today’s standards, that would be considered wasteful.
In the movie, Rietman shows Ryan firing a team of a company in Detroit, which
has been essentially devastated by the economic collapse. One sympathizes with
the individual being canned, however one also sympathizes with Ryan whom the
task has been delegated. The economic turmoil in this area is clearly evident
as he and his “intern” are shown firing an entire company.
Societal views between 2001 and
2009 have changed as well. With such catastrophes as the 911 and the many high
school and college shootings of the past years have jaded many American’s views
of the public. In the movie, Ryan, showing his “intern” the ropes of the CTC
profession, points out several obvious Muslims in the security line at an
airport. As he does, he mentions “random searching’s”. By this, he means that
the TSA will obviously, for a reason only obvious to them, search these
individuals. There have been many stereotypical aspirations made to certain
ethnic groups since the 9111 attacks and are thought by many as unjust.
According to Ryan, these are simply part of AirWorld. Within this association,
Ryan also associates the Asian culture being efficient and fast paced, the
family culture as tedious and time consuming and the elderly population being
the same. One must look at the associations between the book and movie being
different because there is no prejudice within Kirn’s world.
Within
Krin’s world, family is treated as a side note to Ryan’s literary, almost an
annoyance. In the movie, Ryan is far more versed to his family. Ryan, portrayed
by George Clooney, is a loving and caring individual who has all the time in
the world for his family. The familial presence in the movie is one of loving
and caring. In the book, this is lost to Ryan, who is simply self-absorbed and
selfish, having no time for his little sister who becomes estranged from her
husband.
No comments:
Post a Comment